Why Outside Expertise is the Fastest Path to Affiliate Scale

For many brands, the affiliate marketing channel feels like a black box. They know it holds immense potential, but the path to success seems guarded by complex technology, opaque relationships, and the ever-present risk of fraud. Where do you even begin? How do you recruit partners you can trust, and how do you ensure you're building a program that drives real, profitable growth?

To get answers to these critical questions, we sat down with Phil Shapiro, a 23-year affiliate marketing veteran and fractional consultant, to get his playbook. Phil, who has been in the industry since he was 13 and previously founded the affiliate network CPA Trend, explains that for new or struggling programs, hiring outside expertise isn't a cost—it's an accelerator. 

Essentially, it’s the fastest way to build the three pillars of a successful program: trust, technology, and sustainable economics.

Here’s Phil’s playbook for building an affiliate program that scales.

The Trust Deficit: Why New Programs Struggle to Recruit

“...affiliates are often hesitant to work with brand new brands that don't really have a track record...” — Phil Shapiro

According to Phil, affiliates are hesitant about a new brand's payment history, the reliability of their tracking, and whether the program will be managed professionally. This is where a consultant’s value becomes immediately clear:

• Existing Connections: Consultants bring years of high-trust relationships to the table, allowing them to bypass initial brand skepticism.
• A Seal of Approval: Consultant involvement signals to affiliates that the program is serious, the tracking is properly set up, and the payout strategy is sound.
• Reputation: In an industry where "everybody kind of knows everybody," reputation is paramount. A good consultant has built a career on being fair and reliable.

This established trust speeds up recruitment dramatically, turning a process that could take a brand 6-12 months of trial and error into a two to three-month jumpstart.

The 30-Day Blueprint: From Audit to Action

So, what does a consultant actually do in the first 30 days? Phil lays out a clear, three-phase plan designed to build a rock-solid foundation.

Phase 1: Audit and Infrastructure (Week 1-2)

The first 10-14 days are all about auditing.

• For existing programs: This means a deep dive into the current setup. What's the tracking infrastructure? What kinds of partners are active? What's working and what isn't?
• For new programs: This involves learning the brand’s economics. What are the key touchpoints? What user behavior do they want to drive?

This audit phase is critical for the most important technical decision: choosing the right tracking platform. A consultant with deep technical knowledge can identify a platform (like Everflow) that not only fits the brand's budget, but also has the specific functionality required for long-term success.

Phase 2: Flawless Testing and Terms (Week 2-3)

Before a single affiliate is contacted, the technology must be perfected. This phase is dedicated to:

• Tracking Tests: Running extensive tests on every conversion point and event to ensure everything is working flawlessly.
• Finalizing Payouts: Using the business economics from Phase 1 to build a payout strategy that is both attractive to partners and profitable for the brand.
• Setting Terms: Clearly defining what is considered fraud, setting payment terms, and launching new creatives (banners, etc.) for partners to use.

Phase 3: The Test Launch (Week 4)

With the technical foundation set, the program is ready for its first partners. By the end of 30 days, a handful of trusted partners should be onboarded to begin "test data" generation. 

The goal isn't massive volume; it's to confirm that the tracking, payouts, and user flow are all working as planned. This provides the confidence to move into a full-scale recruitment push.

The Most Overlooked Tech: Why Event Tracking is Non-Negotiable

When Phil audits a program, the single biggest technical feature he looks for is event tracking. He notes that many brands don't even know this capability exists, or they lack the technical sophistication to implement it.

Most basic programs only track the final conversion—a lead, an install, or a sale. Event tracking, however, allows you to fire postbacks for valuable user actions deep within the funnel. This could be a registration, free trial, first deposit, or reaching a certain level in a game.

Phil explains why this is a "must-have":

“...it not only puts you in a position to compensate affiliates for events that you're hoping will happen, but it also gives you a crazy amount of data...” — Phil Shapiro

The benefits are twofold:

1. Flexible Compensation: You can pay partners for driving high-intent users, even if they don't make a purchase immediately. This opens up your program to a wider range of partners.
2. Smarter Decisions: You’ll know which partners are driving users who actually engage with your product, allowing you to optimize for quality, not just quantity.

Calculating the Real ROI of a Consultant

Many brands hesitate at the cost of a fractional consultant, but Phil argues this view is shortsighted. The true value is measured in the time you save and the costly mistakes you avoid. He also warns brands to be wary of consultants who make outrageous promises of immediate, massive scale. True expertise is grounded in realism.

Saving on Fraud

This is perhaps the most significant, and immediate, cost saving. New brands are the primary target for fraudulent traffic because they don't know what to look for.

An experienced consultant can spot negative trends and fraudulent activity immediately, saving a brand "20% of spend in some cases minimum on just paying out fraud." That savings alone often offsets a significant portion of the consultant's fee.

Saving on Hiring

Hiring a full-time, in-house affiliate manager is a long and expensive process. Phil estimates it takes months of work, thousands of dollars in recruiting site fees, and hundreds of man-hours to review resumes and conduct interviews. A consultant "plugs right in," saving time and money, getting the program to market months faster.

Ensuring a Profitable Strategy

A consultant's first job is to do a deep dive into the brand’s economics to build a sustainable payout strategy. This prevents a common pitfall: building a high-volume program that looks good on a report but is ultimately unprofitable for the brand.

The Diversity Mandate: A Lesson in Survival

One of Phil's most important lessons was learned the hard way. At his first company, CPA Trend, they found massive success in the dating niche.

“We focused on dating very heavily. 70% of our traffic at one point was Facebook traffic for dating,” Phil recalls. “And I’ll never forget it, on Valentine’s Day of 2014, Facebook completely cut dating from their platform.”

“overnight about 60-70% of our revenue was gone.” — Phil Shapiro

The lesson is seared into his strategy: never put all your eggs in one basket. A core function of a consultant is to build a diverse affiliate program with partners across multiple channels—content, paid social, display, email, and more. This diversity is what provides the stability and resilience to survive the inevitable industry shifts and market changes.

Your Long-Term Playbook: How to Learn from Your Consultant

A consultant engagement isn't meant to be forever. The ultimate goal is to build the program, prove its value, and eventually help the brand hire a full-time manager to take it over. To make this transition successful, brands must avoid treating the consultant as an isolated outsider.

Phil's advice is to "incorporate the consultant into your marketing team." This ensures the affiliate channel's message is aligned with the brand's overall strategy.

He also recommends that the brand assign an internal employee to "shadow" the consultant. This, combined with the "step-by-step documentation" and "CRM of partnerships" that a good consultant provides, ensures that all of the process knowledge and relationships are successfully transferred to the internal brand team.

For brands looking to scale, the affiliate channel doesn't have to be a gamble. By leveraging outside expertise, you aren't just buying connections; you're buying a proven playbook for building a program that is technically sound, fraud-resistant, and economically sustainable from day one.

‍